Key Takeaways
- Nearly 70% of shopping carts are abandoned — most of that is preventable with better checkout design
- Unexpected shipping costs at checkout are the single largest cause of abandonment
- Forced account creation before purchase drives away a significant percentage of first-time buyers
- Simple trust signals (SSL badge, payment logos, return policy link) near the payment form reduce anxiety and increase completions
You've done the hard work. You've got traffic coming to your site, customers are browsing your products, adding items to their cart — and then, inexplicably, they leave. No purchase. No explanation. Just gone. Cart abandonment is one of the most frustrating and most misunderstood problems in eCommerce. Ontario business owners often assume that if someone added something to their cart, they intended to buy — so losing them at that stage feels like a personal failure. In reality, it's almost always a process failure: something in your checkout experience is creating enough friction to push an otherwise willing buyer away. The Baymard Institute has been studying checkout usability for years, and their research consistently shows that a large portion of cart abandonment is preventable with specific, targeted improvements to the checkout process. This post covers the five most common causes we see on Ontario eCommerce sites — most of them built on Magento or WooCommerce — and exactly what to do about each one.
Definition: Cart Abandonment
Cart abandonment occurs when an online shopper adds one or more items to their shopping cart but exits the website before completing the purchase. The cart abandonment rate is calculated as the percentage of shopping carts that are created but not converted into completed orders. Industry average is approximately 68–70%, meaning only 30–32% of carts result in a sale.
Problem 1: Unexpected Shipping Costs Revealed at Checkout
Hiding shipping costs until the final checkout step is the fastest way to lose a customer who was already prepared to buy.
Imagine spending twenty minutes on a website, carefully choosing products, comparing options, and adding your selections to the cart. You click 'Proceed to Checkout,' fill in your address, and then — on the final page, right before you enter your credit card — you discover that shipping is $18.99. Suddenly the $35 item you wanted to buy is actually $54. That's the moment most customers leave.
The issue isn't necessarily the cost itself. Canadian consumers are generally aware that shipping isn't free, especially for businesses that aren't Amazon. The issue is the surprise. Research from the Baymard Institute shows that customers are far more likely to complete a purchase when they know the total cost upfront — even if that total is higher than they'd hoped.
The fix is straightforward: show estimated shipping costs earlier in the process. Add a shipping calculator to your cart page so customers can enter their postal code and see the shipping cost before they start the checkout process. If you offer free shipping over a threshold (e.g., 'free shipping on orders over $75'), display that prominently throughout the shopping experience. For Ontario businesses with fairly predictable shipping costs within the province, a simple flat-rate shipping disclosure on the product page ('Ships within Ontario for $9.95') eliminates the surprise entirely.
- Add a shipping calculator to the cart page — not just at checkout
- Display free shipping thresholds prominently on product pages and the cart
- Consider flat-rate shipping for Ontario customers for price predictability
- Show the estimated delivery date alongside shipping cost — customers want to know when they'll receive their order
Problem 2: Forcing Customers to Create an Account Before Buying
Guest checkout is not optional for a competitive eCommerce store — it is the baseline that customers now expect.
This one is simple to understand and, frustratingly, still very common on Ontario eCommerce sites: to complete your purchase, you must first register for an account. Enter your email, create a password, confirm your email, log back in — and only then can you give us your money.
For repeat customers who are already logged in, this is seamless. For a first-time visitor who just wants to buy one thing and move on with their day, it's a significant obstacle. Many shoppers don't want another account to manage, don't want to receive marketing emails, or simply don't want to spend the time. A meaningful percentage of them will abandon the cart rather than register.
The fix on Magento is straightforward: enable the One Page Checkout extension's guest checkout option, or configure Magento's native guest checkout setting. Place the 'Continue as Guest' button prominently — at least as visually obvious as the 'Sign In' or 'Register' option. After the order is complete, you can invite customers to save their details for next time. That's the right moment — not before they've decided to trust you with their money.
Problem 3: Lack of Trust Signals Near the Payment Form
The payment step is where purchase anxiety peaks — visible security indicators at exactly that moment significantly increase checkout completion.
Online shopping requires a level of trust that in-person shopping doesn't. When a customer enters their credit card number into your website, they're making a judgment about whether your business is legitimate and secure. If your checkout page doesn't visibly signal security and trustworthiness, that judgment may go against you.
The trust signals that matter most at the payment step are: an SSL padlock visible in the browser address bar (your site must have an SSL certificate — there's no excuse in 2014 for a checkout page without HTTPS), payment method logos (Visa, Mastercard, PayPal, Interac Online if you accept it), and a brief security statement near the card fields ('Your payment information is encrypted and never stored on our servers').
Secondary trust signals that help throughout checkout include: a visible phone number or live chat link ('Questions? Call us at 1-800-XXX-XXXX'), a clear returns and refunds policy link, customer review counts or star ratings near the product summary, and a money-back guarantee badge if you offer one. Ontario consumers are increasingly comfortable shopping online, but they still respond strongly to these visible signals of legitimacy.
Experience Signal
We've rebuilt checkout flows for several Ontario eCommerce businesses on Magento, and the pattern is almost always the same: the existing checkout had been set up by developers who prioritised getting the functionality working over optimising the customer experience. Shipping costs were hidden until step three. Account creation was required. The payment page was sparse and had no visible trust signals. Making these specific fixes — none of which required a major rebuild — consistently improved checkout completion rates by 15–25% within the first month.
Frequently Asked Questions
Industry studies consistently put the average cart abandonment rate between 65% and 75%. The Baymard Institute, which tracks this metric rigorously, reported an average of 68.5% in 2013. For Ontario eCommerce stores selling to Canadian consumers, rates in the 65–72% range are typical.
According to multiple studies, unexpected shipping costs revealed at checkout are the leading cause of cart abandonment — accounting for roughly 25–28% of abandonments. When a customer spends time selecting items and then discovers at the last step that shipping adds $15–$25 to their order, the psychological impact is significant enough to push them to a competitor or back to the product search.
Yes, significantly. Forcing customers to create an account before completing a purchase is one of the most well-documented conversion killers in eCommerce. A famous example: when Macys.com added a Guest Checkout option, checkout completions increased dramatically. For Ontario stores using Magento or other platforms, enabling guest checkout is one of the highest-ROI changes you can make.
Sources
Is Your Checkout Process Costing You Sales?
We audit and optimise eCommerce checkout flows for Ontario businesses on Magento, WooCommerce, and Shopify. Let's find out what's driving your abandonment rate and fix it.
Get a Checkout AuditAbout the author
Marcus Lee
Senior Ecommerce Developer
Marcus leads ecommerce development at Webnixon, with deep expertise in Shopify Plus and Adobe Commerce (Magento). He has shipped 40+ scalable ecommerce builds for retailers and B2B manufacturers, leading complex technical integrations with payment gateways, ERP systems, and third-party fulfillment platforms. He writes about ecommerce architecture, platform selection, and the technical decisions that separate high-performing online stores from average ones.
Related Articles
Shopify
The Beginner's Guide to Shopify for Ontario Retailers
Shopify has become the platform of choice for Ontario retailers moving online — and for good reason. It's powerful, relatively affordable, and built for real commerce. Here's everything you need to know to get started.
Web Design
The Truth About DIY Website Builders for Ontario Businesses
Wix, Squarespace, and Weebly have made it genuinely easy to get a website online without writing a single line of code. But for many Ontario businesses, the convenience comes with real limitations that only become apparent a year or two in.
Web Design
How to Improve Website Page Speed: A Practical Guide for Ontario Businesses
Every extra second your website takes to load, you lose visitors. Studies show a one-second delay in page load time reduces conversions by 7%. This guide walks through the specific fixes that will make the biggest difference for a typical Ontario small business website.